Domestic violence and child welfare

Print
Print

Families affected by domestic violence frequently experience involvement in the child welfare system and are often subject to reporting, investigation by child protective services (CPS), and separation from their children on the grounds that they have “failed to protect” them from witnessing domestic violence. Keeping children safe and together with their non-abusive parent can be critical for the survivor and child’s well-being. Studies have demonstrated that separation from a protective parent and placement in the foster care system is perhaps the most key predictor of emotional and behavioral problems in childhood and harms children’s well-being throughout their lives, contributing to worse mental health outcomes and a greater likelihood of involvement in the criminal justice system.

Given the relationship between racial disparities, economic disadvantages, and discrimination against victims of violence and involvement in the child welfare system, the California Partnership to End Domestic Violence (the Partnership) and its partners continue to work to mitigate the harms of the child welfare system on families of color, families experiencing economic disadvantage, and families affected by domestic violence. These organizations are also working to end the practice of removing children from parents solely on the grounds that children have been present during a domestic violence incident.


AB 2085 (Holden) was written into law in January 2023. It removed economic disadvantage as a component of general neglect, making it less likely that children
would be separated from their parents because of their socioeconomic status. In the 2023-24 legislative session, the Partnership co-sponsored SB 1126 (Min) a bill that would have clarified the law on mandated reporting to specify that mandated reporters would not be required to report a child witnessing domestic violence to CPS. The bill was withdrawn prior to a vote on the Senate floor.

Experts

Chris Negri
he/him
Associate Director of Public Policy
California Partnership to End Domestic Violence
Tags
Child welfare
Policy
Eve Sheedy
she/her
Intimate Partner Violence/Domestic Violence Expert & Consultant
Sheedy Consulting, LLC
Tags
Child welfare
Minouche Kandel
she/her
Senior Staff Attorney - LGBTQ, Gender & Reproductive Justice Project
ACLU of Southern California
Tags
LGBTQ+
Policy
Child welfare

Quick facts

Quick fact
Domestic violence and involvement in the child welfare system

There is a strong relationship between experiencing domestic violence and becoming involved in the child welfare system. According to the UCLA Pritzker Center, in 2020, of more than 38,000 open child welfare cases referred to Los Angeles County Department of Child and Family Services, 51.6% involved allegations of domestic violence.

Quick fact
Child removal and domestic violence reporting

Child removal deters survivors from seeking help. In a 2015 survey of 900 advocates, service providers, and attorneys, a majority of respondents said that survivors frequently told them that they were afraid that reporting sexual or domestic violence to police would result in the removal of their children. Eighty-nine percent of respondents also indicated that contact with the police resulted in involvement with child protective services, either sometimes or often.

Quick fact
Disproportionate investigations for Black, Native and Indigenous children

A recent study found that 53% of Black children will be subject to an investigation by child protective services by the time they turn 18. Native and Indigenous children are also over-represented in the child welfare system; the percentage of Native and Indigenous children in foster care is 2.66 times higher than their share of the population. 

Quick fact
Domestic violence exposure and child protective services

Recent guidance issued by the Administration of Children and Families in the Department of Health and Human Services advised that “while exposure to domestic violence is associated with many challenging outcomes for children, learning a child has witnessed domestic violence does not inherently warrant a report to child protective services.”

Sign up to receive new articles and other resources for domestic violence journalism.
Thank you for subscribing.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Thank you for subscribing.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.